Visual and Colorimetry Assessments of Synthetic Resin Impregnated α -Cellulose Decor Paper Laminated Particleboard Surfaces: A Comparative Study
Abstract
This study aims to visually and instrumentally examine the surfaces of particleboards laminated with white decor paper impregnated with α-cellulose-based melamine resin after treatment with five different surface processing agents. Samples of three different types (-A, -B, -C), each with three different grammages, were evaluated according to the TS EN 14323 standard, and color and texture changes were compared. The data were statistically analyzed using ANOVA and the Duncan test. The lowest brightness value (L*: 92.79) was found in samples laminated with 110 g/m² grammage B-type decor paper and treated with water (Wa) and acetone (Ac). The a* color coordinate values were found to be negligible (a*: <1.0), while variations in the b* coordinate were calculated at certain levels. The highest change in the b* coordinate was observed in the acetone-treated surface of the 80 g/m² grammage A-type decor paper (Δb*A80Ac: 0.51), with a difference of 27.4% compared to the control sample. The most significant color changes were found in the 110 g/m² grammage A-type samples treated with water vapor (ΔEA110Wa: 0.61) and the 80 g/m² grammage B-type samples treated with coffee (ΔEB80Co: 0.68); however, these changes were visually undetectable (ΔEB: <0.70). The highest color difference was observed in 90 g/m² grammage C-type samples treated with alcohol (ΔEC90Al: 1.48), followed by acetone (ΔEC90Ac: 1.18) and water (ΔEC90Wa: 0.91). The results indicate a strong correlation between visual perception and colorimetric measurements; however, some marginal differences may be overlooked. This study emphasizes that colorimetric assessments provide more precise results compared to visual evaluations.
References
- Akbulut, T., Ayrılmıs, N. (2024). Yonga Levha Endüstrisi (Particleboard Industry), (Turkish, Abstract in English), İstanbul Üniversitesi-Cerrahpaşa (İÜC) Yayınevi, 2024. Istanbul. 136p.
- Aksu, S. (2009). Fact of decor paper and resin type to physical mechanic and surface quality of par-ticleboard, (MSc thesis), (Turkish, Abstract in English), Graduate School of Natural and Applied Sciences, Department of Forest Products Engineering, Bartın-Turkiye.
- Beğlen, E. (2024). Investigation of the effects of different grammages of decorative paper laminati-ons on particle board properties. (MSc thesis), (Turkish, Abstract in English), Graduate Edu-cation Institute, Department of Forest Products Engineering, Isparta-Turkiye.
- Bhatta, S. R., Tiippana, K., Vahtikari, K., Hughes, M., Kyttä, M. (2017). Sensory and emotional perception of wooden surfaces through fingertip touch. Frontiers in Psychology, 8, 367.
- Brandt, J.P., Shook, S. (2005). Attribute Elicitation: Implications in the Research Context. Wood Fiber Sci., 37, 127–146.
- Broman, N. O. (2001). Aesthetic properties in knotty wood surfaces and their connection with pe-ople's preferences. Journal of Wood Science, 47, 192-198.
- de Morais, I. C., Pereira, A. F. (2015). Perceived sensory characteristics of wood by consumers and trained evaluators. Journal of Sensory Studies, 30(6), 472-483.
- Fengel, D., Wegener, G. (Eds.). (2011). Wood: chemistry, ultrastructure, reactions. Walter de Gruy-ter, Berlinn. 626p.
- Ho, M. C., Chen, J. M., Huang, R. Y., Shen, M. H., Lu, M. C., Liu, C. J. (2015). Numerical analysis on color preference and visual comfort from eye tracking technique. Mathematical Problems in Engineering, 2015(1), 861610.
- Jia, T.-Y., and Niu, X.-T. (2017). Evaluation of color and visual properties of 22 kinds of redwood, Journal of Northwest Forestry University 32(6), 250-258-269.
- Jonsson, O., Lindberg, S., Roos, A., Hugosson, M., Lindström, M. (2008). Consumer perceptions and preferences on solid wood, wood-based panels, and composites: A repertory grid study. Wood and Fiber Science, 663-678.
- Kotradyova, V., Teischinger, A., Ebner, G. (2012). Aesthetic performance of different wood spe-cies: Visual interaction of human being and wood (by analyzing the colour and the texture of wood separately). Innovation in Woodworking Industry and Engineering Design, 1, 25-30.
- Miao, Y., Gao, X., Miao, T., Xu, W. (2024). A study on the visual and tactile perception of oriented strand board combined with consumer-preference analysis. Coatings, 14(8), 1000.
- Muğla, K. (2010). The effect of different finishing materials on the surface properties of mdf, Bartın Üniversity, (MSc thesis), (Turkish, Abstract in English), Graduate School of Natural and Applied Sciences, Department of Forest Products Engineering, Bartın-Turkiye. 107p.
- Nemli, G. (2003). Sentetik Laminant Endüstrisi. (Turkish language), KTÜ Orman Fakültesi Yayınla-rı. Ders Teksirleri Serisi No: 71, Trabzon, 110 s.
- Ross, R.J. (2010). Forest Products Laboratory. Wood Handbook-Wood as an engineering material, General Technical Report FPLGTR-190, Madison, WI., 508p.
- Sahin, H.T., Arslan, M.B., Korkut, S., Sahin, C. (2011). Colour changes of heat‐treated woods of red‐bud maple, European hophornbeam and oak. Color Research & Application, 36(6), 462-466.
- Sahin, C. K., Topay, M., Var, A. A. (2020). A study on suitability of some wood species for lands-cape applications: surface color, hardness and roughness changes at outdoor conditi-ons. Wood Research, 65(3), 395-404.
- Sahin, C. K., Onay, B. (2020). Alternative wood species for playgrounds wood from fruit trees. Wood Research, 65(1), 149-160.
- Sahin, H. T., Beglen, E., Ozkan, U. (2024). Properties of Particle Boards Laminated with Different Grammage Decor Papers. Journal of Engineering Research and Reports, 26(7), 269-277.
- Shmulsky, R., Jones, P. D. (2019). Forest products and wood science: an introduction, John Wiley & Sons Ltd. NY. ISBN:9781119426431, 482p.
- TS EN 14323 (2006). Wood-based panels. Melamine faced boards for interior uses. Test methods, Turkish Standard Institute, Ankara, Turkiye.
- Wei, M., Wang, Y., Ma, S., Luo, M. R. (2017). Chromaticity and characterization of whiteness for surface colors. Optics Express, 25(23), 27981-27994.
- Young, R. (2008). Historical developments in wood chemistry. Turkish Journal of Forestry, 9(1), 1-15.
- Zhu, Y., Wang, Q., Zhao, F. (2023). Wood in office spaces: The impact of different wooden furni-ture on aesthetic evaluation. Frontiers in Psychology, 13, 986627.
Sentetik Reçine Emprenyeli α-Selüloz Dekor Kağıdı Lamine Yonga Levha Yüzeylerinin Görsel ve Kolorimetrik Değerlendirmeleri: Karşı-laştırmalı Bir Çalışma
Abstract
Bu çalışma, beyaz dekor kağıdı ile kaplanmış ve α-selüloz bazlı melamin reçine ile emprenye edilmiş yonga levha yüzeylerinin beş farklı yüzey işlem maddesi ile muamele edildikten sonra görsel ve enstrümantal olarak incelenmesini amaçlamaktadır. Üç farklı tür (-A, -B, -C) ve her biri için üç farklı gramajda kaplanmış numuneler TS EN 14323 standardına göre değerlendirilmiş, renk ve doku değişiklikleri karşılaştırılmıştır. Veriler istatistiksel olarak analiz edilerek ANOVA ve Duncan testi kullanılmıştır. En düşük parlaklık değeri (L*: 92.79) 110 g/m² gramajlı B tipi dekor kağıdı ile kaplanmış ve su (Wa) ile aseton (Ac) ile işlenmiş numunelerde tespit edilmiştir. a* renk koordinatı değerleri ihmal edilebilir düzeyde (a*: <1.0) bulunurken, b* koordinatındaki değişimler belirli seviyelerde hesaplanmıştır. En yüksek b* değişimi, aseton ile işlem görmüş 80 g/m² gramajlı A tipi kağıtta (Δb*A80Ac: 0.51, %27.4 fark) gözlenmiştir. En büyük renk değişimi 110 g/m² gramajlı A tipi su buharı ile işlenmiş (ΔEA110Wa: 0.61) ve 80 g/m² gramajlı B tipi kahve ile işlenmiş (ΔEB80Co: 0.68) numunelerde tespit edilmiştir; ancak bu değişimler görsel olarak fark edilemez düzeydedir (ΔEB: <0.70). En yüksek renk farkı, 90 g/m² gramajlı C tipi alkol ile işlem görmüş numunelerde (ΔEC90Al: 1.48) bulunmuş, bunu aseton (ΔEC90Ac: 1.18) ve su (ΔEC90Wa: 0.91) takip etmiştir. Sonuçlar, görsel algı ile kolorimetrik ölçümler arasında genel olarak iyi bir korelasyon olduğunu, ancak bazı marjinal farklılıkların gözden kaçabileceğini göstermektedir. Çalışma, renk ölçüm analizlerinin görsel değerlendirmelere kıyasla daha hassas sonuçlar sunduğunu vurgulamaktadır.
References
- Akbulut, T., Ayrılmıs, N. (2024). Yonga Levha Endüstrisi (Particleboard Industry), (Turkish, Abstract in English), İstanbul Üniversitesi-Cerrahpaşa (İÜC) Yayınevi, 2024. Istanbul. 136p.
- Aksu, S. (2009). Fact of decor paper and resin type to physical mechanic and surface quality of par-ticleboard, (MSc thesis), (Turkish, Abstract in English), Graduate School of Natural and Applied Sciences, Department of Forest Products Engineering, Bartın-Turkiye.
- Beğlen, E. (2024). Investigation of the effects of different grammages of decorative paper laminati-ons on particle board properties. (MSc thesis), (Turkish, Abstract in English), Graduate Edu-cation Institute, Department of Forest Products Engineering, Isparta-Turkiye.
- Bhatta, S. R., Tiippana, K., Vahtikari, K., Hughes, M., Kyttä, M. (2017). Sensory and emotional perception of wooden surfaces through fingertip touch. Frontiers in Psychology, 8, 367.
- Brandt, J.P., Shook, S. (2005). Attribute Elicitation: Implications in the Research Context. Wood Fiber Sci., 37, 127–146.
- Broman, N. O. (2001). Aesthetic properties in knotty wood surfaces and their connection with pe-ople's preferences. Journal of Wood Science, 47, 192-198.
- de Morais, I. C., Pereira, A. F. (2015). Perceived sensory characteristics of wood by consumers and trained evaluators. Journal of Sensory Studies, 30(6), 472-483.
- Fengel, D., Wegener, G. (Eds.). (2011). Wood: chemistry, ultrastructure, reactions. Walter de Gruy-ter, Berlinn. 626p.
- Ho, M. C., Chen, J. M., Huang, R. Y., Shen, M. H., Lu, M. C., Liu, C. J. (2015). Numerical analysis on color preference and visual comfort from eye tracking technique. Mathematical Problems in Engineering, 2015(1), 861610.
- Jia, T.-Y., and Niu, X.-T. (2017). Evaluation of color and visual properties of 22 kinds of redwood, Journal of Northwest Forestry University 32(6), 250-258-269.
- Jonsson, O., Lindberg, S., Roos, A., Hugosson, M., Lindström, M. (2008). Consumer perceptions and preferences on solid wood, wood-based panels, and composites: A repertory grid study. Wood and Fiber Science, 663-678.
- Kotradyova, V., Teischinger, A., Ebner, G. (2012). Aesthetic performance of different wood spe-cies: Visual interaction of human being and wood (by analyzing the colour and the texture of wood separately). Innovation in Woodworking Industry and Engineering Design, 1, 25-30.
- Miao, Y., Gao, X., Miao, T., Xu, W. (2024). A study on the visual and tactile perception of oriented strand board combined with consumer-preference analysis. Coatings, 14(8), 1000.
- Muğla, K. (2010). The effect of different finishing materials on the surface properties of mdf, Bartın Üniversity, (MSc thesis), (Turkish, Abstract in English), Graduate School of Natural and Applied Sciences, Department of Forest Products Engineering, Bartın-Turkiye. 107p.
- Nemli, G. (2003). Sentetik Laminant Endüstrisi. (Turkish language), KTÜ Orman Fakültesi Yayınla-rı. Ders Teksirleri Serisi No: 71, Trabzon, 110 s.
- Ross, R.J. (2010). Forest Products Laboratory. Wood Handbook-Wood as an engineering material, General Technical Report FPLGTR-190, Madison, WI., 508p.
- Sahin, H.T., Arslan, M.B., Korkut, S., Sahin, C. (2011). Colour changes of heat‐treated woods of red‐bud maple, European hophornbeam and oak. Color Research & Application, 36(6), 462-466.
- Sahin, C. K., Topay, M., Var, A. A. (2020). A study on suitability of some wood species for lands-cape applications: surface color, hardness and roughness changes at outdoor conditi-ons. Wood Research, 65(3), 395-404.
- Sahin, C. K., Onay, B. (2020). Alternative wood species for playgrounds wood from fruit trees. Wood Research, 65(1), 149-160.
- Sahin, H. T., Beglen, E., Ozkan, U. (2024). Properties of Particle Boards Laminated with Different Grammage Decor Papers. Journal of Engineering Research and Reports, 26(7), 269-277.
- Shmulsky, R., Jones, P. D. (2019). Forest products and wood science: an introduction, John Wiley & Sons Ltd. NY. ISBN:9781119426431, 482p.
- TS EN 14323 (2006). Wood-based panels. Melamine faced boards for interior uses. Test methods, Turkish Standard Institute, Ankara, Turkiye.
- Wei, M., Wang, Y., Ma, S., Luo, M. R. (2017). Chromaticity and characterization of whiteness for surface colors. Optics Express, 25(23), 27981-27994.
- Young, R. (2008). Historical developments in wood chemistry. Turkish Journal of Forestry, 9(1), 1-15.
- Zhu, Y., Wang, Q., Zhao, F. (2023). Wood in office spaces: The impact of different wooden furni-ture on aesthetic evaluation. Frontiers in Psychology, 13, 986627.
Details
| Primary Language | English |
|---|---|
| Subjects | Forest Industry Engineering (Other) |
| Journal Section | Research Articles |
| Authors | |
| Early Pub Date | April 21, 2025 |
| Publication Date | |
| Submission Date | December 2, 2024 |
| Acceptance Date | February 12, 2025 |
| Published in Issue | Year 2025 Volume: 27 Issue: 1 |
Bartin Orman Fakultesi Dergisi Editorship,
Bartin University, Faculty of Forestry, Dean Floor No:106, Agdaci District, 74100 Bartin-Turkey.
Fax: +90 (378) 223 5077, Fax: +90 (378) 223 5062,
E-mail: bofdergi@gmail.com