Review
BibTex RIS Cite

Dijital Olgunluk Modelleri Üzerine Bibliyometrik Bir İnceleme

Year 2025, Volume: 18 Issue: 2, 99 - 113, 30.04.2025

Esra Güneş , Yenal Arslan , Hakan Velioğlu , Çetin Karahan

https://doi.org/10.17671/gazibtd.1553658

Abstract

Dijital olgunluk modelleri, kuruluşların dijital dönüşüm yeteneklerini değerlendirmesi ve geliştirmesi için temel araçlardır. Bu modeller, teknoloji, organizasyon, kültür, müşteri gibi çeşitli boyutlar açısından bir kuruluşun dijital dönüşüm durumunu değerlendirmek amacıyla yapılandırılmış ve bütünsel bir yaklaşım sunmaktadır. Bu çalışmanın amacı, dijital olgunluk modelleri üzerine yapılan araştırmalara ait detaylı bir analiz yapmaktır. Bu doğrultuda, Scopus ve Web of Science veri tabanlarında yer alan akademik çalışmalar bibliyometrik analiz yöntemiyle incelenmiştir. Scopus ve Web of Science veri tabanlarında yer alan İngilizce dilindeki ve makale türündeki yayınlar, dijital olgunluk modellerinin olgunluk seviyeleri ve boyutları açısından sistematik bir şekilde incelenmiştir. Bulgular, 2020 yılından itibaren dijital olgunluk modeli konusundaki yayın sayısında artış olduğunu, Almanya ve Türkiye'nin bu alanda en fazla yayın üreten ülkeler arasında yer aldığını göstermiştir. İncelenen modellerde ise en çok teknoloji, strateji ve organizasyon boyutlarının ele alındığı tespit edilmiştir. Çalışmanın, bu alanda araştırma yapmak isteyen araştırmacılara kapsamlı bir genel bakış sunarak, gelecekteki çalışmalar için odaklanılabilecek potansiyel alanları belirlemeleri konusunda yardımcı olacağı düşünülmektedir.

Keywords

dijital olgunluk dijital olgunluk modeli dijital dönüşüm bibliyometrik analiz

References

  • K. Warner, M. Wäger, “Building dynamic capabilities for digital transformation: an ongoing process of strategic renewal”, Long Range Planning, 52(3), pp. 326-349, 2019.
  • I. Iyamu, A. Xu, O. Gómez-Ramírez, A. Ablona, H. Chang, G. McKee, M. Gilbert, “Defining digital public health and the role of digitization, digitalization, and digital transformation: scoping review”, Jmir Public Health and Surveillance, 7(11), e30399, 2021.
  • J. Poeppelbuss, B. Niehaves, A. Simons, & J. Becker, “Maturity models in information systems research: literature search and analysis”, Communications of the Association for Information Systems, 29(1), 27, 2021.
  • A. K. Pani, H. S. Pramanik, “Digital transformation of organizations–defining an emergent construct”, In Re-imagining Diffusion and Adoption of Information Technology and Systems: A Continuing Conversation: IFIP WG 8.6 International Conference on Transfer and Diffusion of IT, TDIT 2020, Proceedings, Part II pp. 511-523, 2020.
  • M. Kupriyanova, E. Evdokimova, I. Solovyova, I. Simikova, “Methods of developing digital maturity models for manufacturing companies”, In E3S Web of Conferences, Vol. 224, p. 02034, 2020.
  • R. Teichert, “Digital transformation maturity: a systematic review of literature” Acta Universitatis Agriculturae Et Silviculturae Mendelianae Brunensis, 67(6), pp. 1673-1687, 2019.
  • P. Jafari, “Investigating a roadmap for digital work practices based on a maturity model approach”. Ghent University. Faculty of Economics and Business Administration, Ghent, Belgium, 2024.
  • V. Okrepilov, "Digital maturity level assessment as an element of digitalization of russian economy", European Proceedings of Social and Behavioural Sciences, 2021.
  • D. V. Kuzin, "Problems of digital maturity in modern business", The World of New Economy, 13(3), pp.89-99, 2019.
  • T. Haryanti, N. A. Rakhmawati, A. P. Subriadi, “The extended digital maturity model”, Big Data and Cognitive Computing, , 7(1), 17, 2023.
  • A. A. Tubis, "Digital maturity assessment model for the organizational and process dimensions", Sustainability, 15(20), 15122, 2023.
  • T. Thordsen, M. Murawski, M. Bick, "How to Measure Digitalization? A Critical Evaluation of Digital Maturity Models", In Responsible Design, Implementation and Use of Information and Communication Technology., 19th IFIP WG 6.11 Conference on e-Business, e-Services, and e-Society, I3E 2020, Skukuza, South Africa, Proceedings, Part I 19 pp. 358-369, Springer International Publishing April 6–8, 2020.
  • S. Perera, X. Jin, P. Das, K. Gunasekara, M. Samaratunga, "A Strategic Framework for Digital Maturity of Design and Construction through a Systematic Review and Application" J. Ind. Inf. Integr., 31, 100413, 2023.
  • C.van Tonder, B. Bossink, C. Schachtebeck, & C. Nieuwenhuizen, "Key dimensions that measure the digital maturity levels of small and medium-sized enterprises (smes)", Journal of Technology Management &Amp; Innovation, 19(1), pp.110-130, 2024.
  • E.Gökalp, V. Martinez, "Digital transformation capability maturity model enabling the assessment of industrial manufacturers", Computer Ind. 132, 103522, 2021.
  • G. Remane, A. Hanelt, F. Wiesboeck, L. Kolbe, “Digital Maturity in Traditional Industries—An Exploratory Analysis”, In Proceedings of the 25th European Conference on Information Systems (ECIS), Guimarães, Portugal, 5–10 June 2017.
  • South Australian Government, Department of the Premier and Cabinet, "The Digital Strategy Toolkit", https://www.dpc.sa.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0008/46565/Digital_Transformation_Toolkit_Guide.pdf , Erişim tarihi: 18.09.2024
  • Türkiye Cumhuriyeti Cumhurbaşkanlığı, Strateji ve Bütçe Başkanlığı, "On İkinci Kalkınma Planı (2024-2028)", p.234 (964.4), 2023 https://www.sbb.gov.tr/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/On-Ikinci-Kalkinma-Plani_2024-2028_11122023.pdf, Erişim tarihi: 10.07.2024.
  • F. Blatz, R. Bulander & M. Dietel, "Maturity model of digitization for SMEs", In 2018 IEEE International Conference on Engineering, Technology and Innovation (ICE/ITMC), pp.1-9, June, 2018.
  • G. Erboz, H. Abbas, S. Nosratabadi, “Investigating supply chain research trends amid Covid-19: a bibliometric analysis”. Management Research Review, 46(3), pp. 413-436, 2023.
  • M. A. Khan, D. Pattnaik, R. Ashraf, I. Ali, S. Kumar, N. Donthu, “Value of special issues in the journal of business research: A bibliometric analysis”, Journal of business research, 125, pp.295-313. 2021.
  • N. Donthu, S. Kumar, D. Mukherjee, N. Pandey, L. Marc, “How to conduct a bibliometric analysis: an overview and guidelines”, Journal of Business Research, 133, pp.285-296, 2021.
  • W. Hassan, A. E. Duarte, “Bibliometric analysis: A few suggestions”, Current Problems in Cardiology, Volume 49, Issue 8, 2024.
  • L. Ochoa-Urrego, J. Peña-Reyes, “Digital maturity models: a systematic literature review”, Management for Professionals, pp.71-85, 2021.
  • M. Al-Ali, A. Marks, “A digital maturity model for the education enterprise”, Perspectives: Policy and Practice in Higher Education, 26(2), pp.47-58, 2022.
  • N. Halpern, T. Budd, P. Suau-Sanchez, S. Bråthen, D. Mwesiumo, “Conceptualising airport digital maturity and dimensions of technological and organisational transformation”, Journal of Airport Management, 15(2), pp. 182-203, 2021.
  • E. E. Nebati, B. Ayvaz, A. O. Kusakci, “Digital transformation in the defense industry: A maturity model combining SF-AHP and SF-TODIM approaches”, Applied Soft Computing, 132, 109896, 2023.
  • O. Valdez-de-Leon, “A digital maturity model for telecommunications service providers”, Technology innovation management review, 6(8), 2016.
  • R. Duncan, R. Eden, L. Woods, I. Wong, C. Sullivan, “Synthesizing dimensions of digital maturity in hospitals: systematic review”, Journal of Medical Internet Research, 24(3), e32994, 2022.
  • N. Kaszás, I. Ernszt, B. Jakab, “The Emergence of Organizaional and Human Factors in Digital Maturity Models”, Management: Journal of Contemporary Management Issues, 28(1), pp. 123-135, 2023.
  • D. Merdin, F. Ersöz, H. Taşkın, “Digital Transformation: Digital Maturity Model for Turkish Businesses”, Gazi University Journal of Science, 36(1), pp. 263-282, 2022.
  • G. Vial, “Understanding digital transformation: A review and a research agenda”. J. Strateg. Inf. Syst. 28, pp.118–144, 2019.
  • A. K Feroz, H. Zo, A. Chiravuri, “Digital transformation and environmental sustainability: a review and research agenda”, Sustainability, 13(3), 1530, 2021.
  • J. Yan, J. Li, X. Li, & Y. Liu, "Digital transition and the clean renewable energy adoption in rural family: evidence from broadband china", Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution, 11, 2023.
  • L. Zhao, Y. Zhang, & H. Zhang, "Research on the impact of digital literacy on farmer households’ green cooking energy consumption: evidence from rural china", International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 19(20), 13464, 2022.
  • H. Wen, C. Lee, & Z. Song, "Digitalization and environment: how does ict affect enterprise environmental performance?", Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 28(39), pp.54826-54841, 2021.
  • J. Lan, H. Wen, "Industrial digitalization and energy intensity: evidence from china’s manufacturing sector". Energy Research Letters, 2(2), 2021.
  • M. A. Abdullah, “Digital maturity of the Egyptian universities: goal-oriented project planning model”, Studies in Higher Education, pp.1-23, 2023
  • A. Altundag, M. Wynn, “Advanced Analytics and Data Management in the Procurement Function: An Aviation Industry Case Study”, Electronics, 13(8), pp.1554, 2024.
  • A. Aras, G. Büyüközkan, “Digital Transformation Journey Guidance: A Holistic Digital Maturity Model Based on a Systematic Literature Review”, Systems, 11(4), pp.213, 2023.
  • A. Aristovnik, D. Ravšelj, E. Murko, “Decoding the Digital Landscape: An Empirically Validated Model for Assessing Digitalisation across Public Administration Levels”, Administrative Sciences, 14(3), pp. 41, 2024.
  • A. S. Barry, S. Assoul, N. Souissi, “Strengths and Weaknesses of Digital Maturity Models”, Journal of Computer Science, 19 (6), pp. 727.738, 2023.
  • T. Benazzouz, K. Auhmani, “Digital maturity assessment model for pharmaceutical supply chain: a patient and hospital-centred development”, International Journal of Healthcare Management, 17(2), pp. 261-284, 2024.
  • Bouncken, R., & Schmitt, F. SME family firms and strategic digital transformation: inverting dualisms related to overconfidence and centralization. Journal of Small Business Strategy, 32(3), 1-17, (2022).
  • S. Bozkus Kahyaoglu, S. Durst, E. Coskun, “To digitalize or not? COVID effect in medium sized companies based on three cases”, EDPACS, 68(4), pp.1-25, 2023.
  • G. Büyüközkan, M. Güler, “Analysis of companies’ digital maturity by hesitant fuzzy linguistic MCDM methods”, Journal of Intelligent & Fuzzy Systems, 38(1), pp.1119-1132, 2020.
  • T. Červinka, “Digital transformation of strategic management of SMEs in the Czech Republic”, Journal of Information and Organizational Sciences, 47(2), pp. 387-400, 2023.
  • B. Cognet, J. P. Pernot, L. Rivest, C. Danjou, “Digital maturity models: comparing manual and semi-automatic similarity assessment frameworks”, International Journal of Product Lifecycle Management, 13(4), pp.291-316, 2021.
  • B. Cognet, J. P. Pernot, L. Rivest, C. Danjou, “Systematic comparison of digital maturity assessment models”, Journal of Industrial and Production Engineering, 40(7), pp. 519-537, 2023.
  • M. Ćurak, M. Duvnjak, M. Pervan, “The relationship between the digital maturity and efficiency of Croatian non-life insurers: Exploratory research”, Journal of Economics and Management, 46(1), pp.55-78, 2024.
  • M. Diller, M. Asen, T. Späth, “The effects of personality traits on digital transformation: Evidence from German tax consulting”, International Journal of Accounting Information Systems, 37, 2020.
  • S. Eichstädt, M. Gruber, A. P. Vedurmudi, “Integrating metrological principles into the Internet of Things: a digital maturity model for sensor network metrology”, tm-Technisches Messen, 91(1), pp.17-31, 2024.
  • M. Guarino, M. A. Di Palma, T. Menini, M. Gallo, “Digital transformation of cultural institutions: a statistical analysis of Italian and Campania GLAMs”, Quality & quantity, 54, pp. 1445-1464, 2020.
  • X. Han, M. Zhang, Y. Hu, Y. Huang, “Study on the Digital Transformation Capability of Cost Consultation Enterprises Based on Maturity Model”, Sustainability, 14(16), 10038, 2022.
  • I. Herceg, V. Kuč, V. M. Mijušković, T. Herceg, “Challenges and driving forces for industry 4.0 implementation”, Sustainability, 12(10), 4208, 2020.
  • V. Hrosul, D. Galoyan, T.Mkrtchyan, A. Volosov, H. Balamut, A. Kolesnyk, "Assessment of digital maturity, the transformation of business models in the context of digital transformation", REICE: Revista Electrónica de Investigación en Ciencias Económicas, 11(32), pp. 81-105, 2023.
  • A. Imboden, S. Grèzes-Bürcher, D. Fumeaux, E. Fragnière, M. Fux, “Piloting a digital maturity model for smart destinations”, International Journal of Technology Marketing, 16(4), pp.304-317, 2022.
  • T. Kafel, A. Wodecka-hyjek, R. Kusa, “Multidimensional public sector organizations' digital maturity model”, Administration & Public Management Review, (37), 2021.
  • K. J. Kupilas, V. Rodríguez Montequín, M. Díaz Piloñeta, C. Alonso Álvarez, “Sustainability and digitalisation: Using Means-End Chain Theory to determine the key elements of the digital maturity model for research and development organisations with the aspect of sustainability”, Advances in production engineering and management, 2022.
  • L. Ladu, C. Koch, P. A. Ashari, K. Blind, P. Castka, “Technology adoption and digital maturity in the conformity assessment industry: Empirical evidence from an international study”, Technology in Society, 77, 102564, 2024.
  • Y. Liu, F. Pan, “Digital transformation value creating of manufacturing enterprises based on the Internet of Things and data encryption technology”, Soft Computing,, pp.1-12, 2023.
  • I. Merzlov, E. Shilova, “A Digital Maturity Model for Organizations: An Approach to Assessment and Case Study”, International Journal of Systematic Innovation, 7(2), pp. 22-36, 2022.
  • C. Minonne, R. Wyss, K. Schwer, D. Wirz, C. Hitz, “Digital maturity variables and their impact on the enterprise architecture layers”, Problems and perspectives in management,16, Iss. 4, pp. 141-154, 2018. P. Phiri, H. Cavalini, S. Shetty, G. Delanerolle, “Digital Maturity Consulting and Strategizing to Optimize Services: Overview”, Journal of Medical Internet Research, 25, e37545, 2023.
  • W. G. Ryan, A. Fenton, W. Ahmed, P. Scarf, “Recognizing events 4.0: The digital maturity of events”, International Journal of Event and Festival Management, 11(1), pp. 47-68, 2020.
  • Á. Sándor, Á. Gubán, “A measuring tool for the digital maturity of small and medium-sized enterprises”, Management and Production Engineering Review,14, 2021.
  • Á. Sándor, Á. Gubán, “A multi-dimensional model to the digital maturity life-cycle for smes”, International Journal of Information Systems and Project Management, 10(3), pp. 58-81, 2022.
  • F. J. Santos, C. Guzmán, P. Ahumada, “Assessing the digital transformation in agri-food cooperatives and its determinants”, Journal of Rural Studies, pp.105, 103168, 2024.
  • P. P. Senna, A. C. Barros, J. B. Roca, A. Azevedo, “Development of a digital maturity model for Industry 4.0 based on the technology-organization-environment framework”, Computers & Industrial Engineering,, pp. 185, 109645, 2023.
  • R. Teichert, “A Model for Assessing Digital Transformation Maturity for Service Provider Organizations”, European Journal of Business Science and Technology, pp. 205, 2023.
  • T. Thordsen, M. Bick, “A decade of digital maturity models: much ado about nothing?” Information Systems and e-Business Management, pp. 1-30, 2023.
  • C. E. Tømte, J. Smedsrud, “Governance and digital transformation in schools with 1: 1 tablet coverage”, 2023.
  • M. Voss, D. Jaspert, C. Ahlfeld, L. Sucke, “Developing a digital maturity model for the sales processes of industrial projects”, Journal of Personal Selling & Sales Management, 44(1), pp.7-28, 2024.
  • C. Williams, B. Krumay, D. Schallmo, E. Scornavacca, “Digital Maturity Model for SMEs: Validation Through a Mixed-Method Approach”, Pacific Asia Journal of the Association for Information Systems, 16(1), 2, 2024.
  • C. A. Williams, D. Schallmo, E. Scornavacca, “How applicable are digital maturity models to SMEs?: A conceptual framework and empirical validation approach.” International Journal of Innovation Management, 26(03), 2240010, 2022.
  • L. Woods, R. Eden, R. Duncan, Z. Kodiyattu, S. Macklin, C. Sullivan, “Which one? A suggested approach for evaluating digital health maturity models”, Frontiers in Digital Health, 4, 246, 2022.
  • F. Zaoui, N. Souissi, “Digital Maturity Assessment – A Case Study”, Journal of Computer Science, 18 (8), pp. 724-731, 2022.
  • T. Von Leipzig, M. Gamp, D. Manz, K. Schöttle, P. Ohlhausen, G.Oosthuizen, D. Palm, K. Von Leipzig, "Initialising customer-orientated digital transformation in enterprises", Procedia Manufacturing, 8, pp. 517-524, 2017.
  • D. Fayon, M. Tartar, “Transformation digitale: 5 leviers pour l'entreprise”, Pearson Education France, 2014.

A Bibliometric Analysis on Digital Maturity Models

Year 2025, Volume: 18 Issue: 2, 99 - 113, 30.04.2025

Esra Güneş , Yenal Arslan , Hakan Velioğlu , Çetin Karahan

https://doi.org/10.17671/gazibtd.1553658

Abstract

Digital maturity models are essential tools for organisations to assess and improve their digital transformation capabilities. These models provide a structured and holistic approach to assessing an organisation's digital transformation status in terms of various dimensions such as technology, organisation, culture, customers, etc. The purpose of this study is to conduct a detailed analysis of the research on digital maturity models. In this direction, academic studies in Scopus and Web of Science databases were analysed by bibliometric analysis method. English-language article-type publications in Scopus and Web of Science databases were systematically analysed in terms of maturity levels and dimensions of digital maturity models. The findings show that there has been an increase in the number of publications on digital maturity models since 2020 and that Germany and Turkey are among the countries that produce the most publications in this field. In the models examined, it was found that technology, strategy and organisation dimensions were mostly addressed. It is thought that the study will help researchers who want to conduct research in this field to identify potential areas to focus on for future studies by providing a comprehensive overview.

Keywords

digital maturity digital maturity model digital transformation bibliometric analysis

References

  • K. Warner, M. Wäger, “Building dynamic capabilities for digital transformation: an ongoing process of strategic renewal”, Long Range Planning, 52(3), pp. 326-349, 2019.
  • I. Iyamu, A. Xu, O. Gómez-Ramírez, A. Ablona, H. Chang, G. McKee, M. Gilbert, “Defining digital public health and the role of digitization, digitalization, and digital transformation: scoping review”, Jmir Public Health and Surveillance, 7(11), e30399, 2021.
  • J. Poeppelbuss, B. Niehaves, A. Simons, & J. Becker, “Maturity models in information systems research: literature search and analysis”, Communications of the Association for Information Systems, 29(1), 27, 2021.
  • A. K. Pani, H. S. Pramanik, “Digital transformation of organizations–defining an emergent construct”, In Re-imagining Diffusion and Adoption of Information Technology and Systems: A Continuing Conversation: IFIP WG 8.6 International Conference on Transfer and Diffusion of IT, TDIT 2020, Proceedings, Part II pp. 511-523, 2020.
  • M. Kupriyanova, E. Evdokimova, I. Solovyova, I. Simikova, “Methods of developing digital maturity models for manufacturing companies”, In E3S Web of Conferences, Vol. 224, p. 02034, 2020.
  • R. Teichert, “Digital transformation maturity: a systematic review of literature” Acta Universitatis Agriculturae Et Silviculturae Mendelianae Brunensis, 67(6), pp. 1673-1687, 2019.
  • P. Jafari, “Investigating a roadmap for digital work practices based on a maturity model approach”. Ghent University. Faculty of Economics and Business Administration, Ghent, Belgium, 2024.
  • V. Okrepilov, "Digital maturity level assessment as an element of digitalization of russian economy", European Proceedings of Social and Behavioural Sciences, 2021.
  • D. V. Kuzin, "Problems of digital maturity in modern business", The World of New Economy, 13(3), pp.89-99, 2019.
  • T. Haryanti, N. A. Rakhmawati, A. P. Subriadi, “The extended digital maturity model”, Big Data and Cognitive Computing, , 7(1), 17, 2023.
  • A. A. Tubis, "Digital maturity assessment model for the organizational and process dimensions", Sustainability, 15(20), 15122, 2023.
  • T. Thordsen, M. Murawski, M. Bick, "How to Measure Digitalization? A Critical Evaluation of Digital Maturity Models", In Responsible Design, Implementation and Use of Information and Communication Technology., 19th IFIP WG 6.11 Conference on e-Business, e-Services, and e-Society, I3E 2020, Skukuza, South Africa, Proceedings, Part I 19 pp. 358-369, Springer International Publishing April 6–8, 2020.
  • S. Perera, X. Jin, P. Das, K. Gunasekara, M. Samaratunga, "A Strategic Framework for Digital Maturity of Design and Construction through a Systematic Review and Application" J. Ind. Inf. Integr., 31, 100413, 2023.
  • C.van Tonder, B. Bossink, C. Schachtebeck, & C. Nieuwenhuizen, "Key dimensions that measure the digital maturity levels of small and medium-sized enterprises (smes)", Journal of Technology Management &Amp; Innovation, 19(1), pp.110-130, 2024.
  • E.Gökalp, V. Martinez, "Digital transformation capability maturity model enabling the assessment of industrial manufacturers", Computer Ind. 132, 103522, 2021.
  • G. Remane, A. Hanelt, F. Wiesboeck, L. Kolbe, “Digital Maturity in Traditional Industries—An Exploratory Analysis”, In Proceedings of the 25th European Conference on Information Systems (ECIS), Guimarães, Portugal, 5–10 June 2017.
  • South Australian Government, Department of the Premier and Cabinet, "The Digital Strategy Toolkit", https://www.dpc.sa.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0008/46565/Digital_Transformation_Toolkit_Guide.pdf , Erişim tarihi: 18.09.2024
  • Türkiye Cumhuriyeti Cumhurbaşkanlığı, Strateji ve Bütçe Başkanlığı, "On İkinci Kalkınma Planı (2024-2028)", p.234 (964.4), 2023 https://www.sbb.gov.tr/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/On-Ikinci-Kalkinma-Plani_2024-2028_11122023.pdf, Erişim tarihi: 10.07.2024.
  • F. Blatz, R. Bulander & M. Dietel, "Maturity model of digitization for SMEs", In 2018 IEEE International Conference on Engineering, Technology and Innovation (ICE/ITMC), pp.1-9, June, 2018.
  • G. Erboz, H. Abbas, S. Nosratabadi, “Investigating supply chain research trends amid Covid-19: a bibliometric analysis”. Management Research Review, 46(3), pp. 413-436, 2023.
  • M. A. Khan, D. Pattnaik, R. Ashraf, I. Ali, S. Kumar, N. Donthu, “Value of special issues in the journal of business research: A bibliometric analysis”, Journal of business research, 125, pp.295-313. 2021.
  • N. Donthu, S. Kumar, D. Mukherjee, N. Pandey, L. Marc, “How to conduct a bibliometric analysis: an overview and guidelines”, Journal of Business Research, 133, pp.285-296, 2021.
  • W. Hassan, A. E. Duarte, “Bibliometric analysis: A few suggestions”, Current Problems in Cardiology, Volume 49, Issue 8, 2024.
  • L. Ochoa-Urrego, J. Peña-Reyes, “Digital maturity models: a systematic literature review”, Management for Professionals, pp.71-85, 2021.
  • M. Al-Ali, A. Marks, “A digital maturity model for the education enterprise”, Perspectives: Policy and Practice in Higher Education, 26(2), pp.47-58, 2022.
  • N. Halpern, T. Budd, P. Suau-Sanchez, S. Bråthen, D. Mwesiumo, “Conceptualising airport digital maturity and dimensions of technological and organisational transformation”, Journal of Airport Management, 15(2), pp. 182-203, 2021.
  • E. E. Nebati, B. Ayvaz, A. O. Kusakci, “Digital transformation in the defense industry: A maturity model combining SF-AHP and SF-TODIM approaches”, Applied Soft Computing, 132, 109896, 2023.
  • O. Valdez-de-Leon, “A digital maturity model for telecommunications service providers”, Technology innovation management review, 6(8), 2016.
  • R. Duncan, R. Eden, L. Woods, I. Wong, C. Sullivan, “Synthesizing dimensions of digital maturity in hospitals: systematic review”, Journal of Medical Internet Research, 24(3), e32994, 2022.
  • N. Kaszás, I. Ernszt, B. Jakab, “The Emergence of Organizaional and Human Factors in Digital Maturity Models”, Management: Journal of Contemporary Management Issues, 28(1), pp. 123-135, 2023.
  • D. Merdin, F. Ersöz, H. Taşkın, “Digital Transformation: Digital Maturity Model for Turkish Businesses”, Gazi University Journal of Science, 36(1), pp. 263-282, 2022.
  • G. Vial, “Understanding digital transformation: A review and a research agenda”. J. Strateg. Inf. Syst. 28, pp.118–144, 2019.
  • A. K Feroz, H. Zo, A. Chiravuri, “Digital transformation and environmental sustainability: a review and research agenda”, Sustainability, 13(3), 1530, 2021.
  • J. Yan, J. Li, X. Li, & Y. Liu, "Digital transition and the clean renewable energy adoption in rural family: evidence from broadband china", Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution, 11, 2023.
  • L. Zhao, Y. Zhang, & H. Zhang, "Research on the impact of digital literacy on farmer households’ green cooking energy consumption: evidence from rural china", International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 19(20), 13464, 2022.
  • H. Wen, C. Lee, & Z. Song, "Digitalization and environment: how does ict affect enterprise environmental performance?", Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 28(39), pp.54826-54841, 2021.
  • J. Lan, H. Wen, "Industrial digitalization and energy intensity: evidence from china’s manufacturing sector". Energy Research Letters, 2(2), 2021.
  • M. A. Abdullah, “Digital maturity of the Egyptian universities: goal-oriented project planning model”, Studies in Higher Education, pp.1-23, 2023
  • A. Altundag, M. Wynn, “Advanced Analytics and Data Management in the Procurement Function: An Aviation Industry Case Study”, Electronics, 13(8), pp.1554, 2024.
  • A. Aras, G. Büyüközkan, “Digital Transformation Journey Guidance: A Holistic Digital Maturity Model Based on a Systematic Literature Review”, Systems, 11(4), pp.213, 2023.
  • A. Aristovnik, D. Ravšelj, E. Murko, “Decoding the Digital Landscape: An Empirically Validated Model for Assessing Digitalisation across Public Administration Levels”, Administrative Sciences, 14(3), pp. 41, 2024.
  • A. S. Barry, S. Assoul, N. Souissi, “Strengths and Weaknesses of Digital Maturity Models”, Journal of Computer Science, 19 (6), pp. 727.738, 2023.
  • T. Benazzouz, K. Auhmani, “Digital maturity assessment model for pharmaceutical supply chain: a patient and hospital-centred development”, International Journal of Healthcare Management, 17(2), pp. 261-284, 2024.
  • Bouncken, R., & Schmitt, F. SME family firms and strategic digital transformation: inverting dualisms related to overconfidence and centralization. Journal of Small Business Strategy, 32(3), 1-17, (2022).
  • S. Bozkus Kahyaoglu, S. Durst, E. Coskun, “To digitalize or not? COVID effect in medium sized companies based on three cases”, EDPACS, 68(4), pp.1-25, 2023.
  • G. Büyüközkan, M. Güler, “Analysis of companies’ digital maturity by hesitant fuzzy linguistic MCDM methods”, Journal of Intelligent & Fuzzy Systems, 38(1), pp.1119-1132, 2020.
  • T. Červinka, “Digital transformation of strategic management of SMEs in the Czech Republic”, Journal of Information and Organizational Sciences, 47(2), pp. 387-400, 2023.
  • B. Cognet, J. P. Pernot, L. Rivest, C. Danjou, “Digital maturity models: comparing manual and semi-automatic similarity assessment frameworks”, International Journal of Product Lifecycle Management, 13(4), pp.291-316, 2021.
  • B. Cognet, J. P. Pernot, L. Rivest, C. Danjou, “Systematic comparison of digital maturity assessment models”, Journal of Industrial and Production Engineering, 40(7), pp. 519-537, 2023.
  • M. Ćurak, M. Duvnjak, M. Pervan, “The relationship between the digital maturity and efficiency of Croatian non-life insurers: Exploratory research”, Journal of Economics and Management, 46(1), pp.55-78, 2024.
  • M. Diller, M. Asen, T. Späth, “The effects of personality traits on digital transformation: Evidence from German tax consulting”, International Journal of Accounting Information Systems, 37, 2020.
  • S. Eichstädt, M. Gruber, A. P. Vedurmudi, “Integrating metrological principles into the Internet of Things: a digital maturity model for sensor network metrology”, tm-Technisches Messen, 91(1), pp.17-31, 2024.
  • M. Guarino, M. A. Di Palma, T. Menini, M. Gallo, “Digital transformation of cultural institutions: a statistical analysis of Italian and Campania GLAMs”, Quality & quantity, 54, pp. 1445-1464, 2020.
  • X. Han, M. Zhang, Y. Hu, Y. Huang, “Study on the Digital Transformation Capability of Cost Consultation Enterprises Based on Maturity Model”, Sustainability, 14(16), 10038, 2022.
  • I. Herceg, V. Kuč, V. M. Mijušković, T. Herceg, “Challenges and driving forces for industry 4.0 implementation”, Sustainability, 12(10), 4208, 2020.
  • V. Hrosul, D. Galoyan, T.Mkrtchyan, A. Volosov, H. Balamut, A. Kolesnyk, "Assessment of digital maturity, the transformation of business models in the context of digital transformation", REICE: Revista Electrónica de Investigación en Ciencias Económicas, 11(32), pp. 81-105, 2023.
  • A. Imboden, S. Grèzes-Bürcher, D. Fumeaux, E. Fragnière, M. Fux, “Piloting a digital maturity model for smart destinations”, International Journal of Technology Marketing, 16(4), pp.304-317, 2022.
  • T. Kafel, A. Wodecka-hyjek, R. Kusa, “Multidimensional public sector organizations' digital maturity model”, Administration & Public Management Review, (37), 2021.
  • K. J. Kupilas, V. Rodríguez Montequín, M. Díaz Piloñeta, C. Alonso Álvarez, “Sustainability and digitalisation: Using Means-End Chain Theory to determine the key elements of the digital maturity model for research and development organisations with the aspect of sustainability”, Advances in production engineering and management, 2022.
  • L. Ladu, C. Koch, P. A. Ashari, K. Blind, P. Castka, “Technology adoption and digital maturity in the conformity assessment industry: Empirical evidence from an international study”, Technology in Society, 77, 102564, 2024.
  • Y. Liu, F. Pan, “Digital transformation value creating of manufacturing enterprises based on the Internet of Things and data encryption technology”, Soft Computing,, pp.1-12, 2023.
  • I. Merzlov, E. Shilova, “A Digital Maturity Model for Organizations: An Approach to Assessment and Case Study”, International Journal of Systematic Innovation, 7(2), pp. 22-36, 2022.
  • C. Minonne, R. Wyss, K. Schwer, D. Wirz, C. Hitz, “Digital maturity variables and their impact on the enterprise architecture layers”, Problems and perspectives in management,16, Iss. 4, pp. 141-154, 2018. P. Phiri, H. Cavalini, S. Shetty, G. Delanerolle, “Digital Maturity Consulting and Strategizing to Optimize Services: Overview”, Journal of Medical Internet Research, 25, e37545, 2023.
  • W. G. Ryan, A. Fenton, W. Ahmed, P. Scarf, “Recognizing events 4.0: The digital maturity of events”, International Journal of Event and Festival Management, 11(1), pp. 47-68, 2020.
  • Á. Sándor, Á. Gubán, “A measuring tool for the digital maturity of small and medium-sized enterprises”, Management and Production Engineering Review,14, 2021.
  • Á. Sándor, Á. Gubán, “A multi-dimensional model to the digital maturity life-cycle for smes”, International Journal of Information Systems and Project Management, 10(3), pp. 58-81, 2022.
  • F. J. Santos, C. Guzmán, P. Ahumada, “Assessing the digital transformation in agri-food cooperatives and its determinants”, Journal of Rural Studies, pp.105, 103168, 2024.
  • P. P. Senna, A. C. Barros, J. B. Roca, A. Azevedo, “Development of a digital maturity model for Industry 4.0 based on the technology-organization-environment framework”, Computers & Industrial Engineering,, pp. 185, 109645, 2023.
  • R. Teichert, “A Model for Assessing Digital Transformation Maturity for Service Provider Organizations”, European Journal of Business Science and Technology, pp. 205, 2023.
  • T. Thordsen, M. Bick, “A decade of digital maturity models: much ado about nothing?” Information Systems and e-Business Management, pp. 1-30, 2023.
  • C. E. Tømte, J. Smedsrud, “Governance and digital transformation in schools with 1: 1 tablet coverage”, 2023.
  • M. Voss, D. Jaspert, C. Ahlfeld, L. Sucke, “Developing a digital maturity model for the sales processes of industrial projects”, Journal of Personal Selling & Sales Management, 44(1), pp.7-28, 2024.
  • C. Williams, B. Krumay, D. Schallmo, E. Scornavacca, “Digital Maturity Model for SMEs: Validation Through a Mixed-Method Approach”, Pacific Asia Journal of the Association for Information Systems, 16(1), 2, 2024.
  • C. A. Williams, D. Schallmo, E. Scornavacca, “How applicable are digital maturity models to SMEs?: A conceptual framework and empirical validation approach.” International Journal of Innovation Management, 26(03), 2240010, 2022.
  • L. Woods, R. Eden, R. Duncan, Z. Kodiyattu, S. Macklin, C. Sullivan, “Which one? A suggested approach for evaluating digital health maturity models”, Frontiers in Digital Health, 4, 246, 2022.
  • F. Zaoui, N. Souissi, “Digital Maturity Assessment – A Case Study”, Journal of Computer Science, 18 (8), pp. 724-731, 2022.
  • T. Von Leipzig, M. Gamp, D. Manz, K. Schöttle, P. Ohlhausen, G.Oosthuizen, D. Palm, K. Von Leipzig, "Initialising customer-orientated digital transformation in enterprises", Procedia Manufacturing, 8, pp. 517-524, 2017.
  • D. Fayon, M. Tartar, “Transformation digitale: 5 leviers pour l'entreprise”, Pearson Education France, 2014.
There are 78 citations in total.

Details

Primary Language Turkish
Subjects Information Systems (Other)
Journal Section Derleme
Authors

Esra Güneş 0009-0006-7384-2796

Yenal Arslan 0000-0002-1776-6091

Hakan Velioğlu 0000-0003-2220-3602

Çetin Karahan 0000-0002-8697-9162

Publication Date April 30, 2025
Submission Date September 20, 2024
Acceptance Date December 26, 2024
Published in Issue Year 2025 Volume: 18 Issue: 2

Cite

APA Güneş, E., Arslan, Y., Velioğlu, H., Karahan, Ç. (2025). Dijital Olgunluk Modelleri Üzerine Bibliyometrik Bir İnceleme. Bilişim Teknolojileri Dergisi, 18(2), 99-113. https://doi.org/10.17671/gazibtd.1553658
 Download Cover Image